Update: Because we've found (large) external funding, it's only fair to return everyone's personal donations here. The Manifund team tells me they'll revert the donations in the upcoming weeks. Thanks everyone here for their contributions--especially the token of trust means a lot to us.
Candidate gene studies are known to be pretty horrible (a vast, vast majority of them do not replicate), and the correct standard are GWASes. My understanding is that your proposed targets DEC2 and ADRB1 are both candidate gene studies, and neither of them show up in the GWAS Catalog (https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/nSwaDrHunt3ohh9Et/cause-area-short-sleeper-genes?commentId=GCQf5qjG4LyEdEJov). Given that, I am quite skeptical of your specific gene targets. I am unfamiliar with the literature though and haven't read any of the references in your bibliography, and would change my mind if there has been any GWAS-based evidence in favor of DEC2 and ADRB1 recently (none showed up in the GWAS Catalog 2 years ago, according to the above EA forums). With that said, I'm very excited about the idea of sleep-reduction (and thank you for doing this work), and I'd be much more optimistic about this project if your gene targets were chosen via GWAS.
I asked Isaak to put this on Manifund as soon as I saw his proposal:
I'm anti-sleeping-pilled: I think reducing sleep needs would be very beneficial to the world, and on a personal level have experimented with polyphasic sleep.
Though I'm no expert in biology and have no insight on how feasible this is, I'm very impressed with the credentials of this team and their advisors.
I strongly believe in Isaak himself, having worked with him on Future Forum and seen his trajectory since. (We asked him to serve as a Manifund regrantor in 2023.) I'd expect any project that Isaak's on to deliver extraordinary outcomes.
While it's different from the AI safety work that Manifund is mostly known for nowadays, ambitious moonshots like this are what I'm most personally interested in funding, and I'm excited to be able to support this initiative.
Comments
Isaak Freeman
over 1 year agoUpdate: Because we've found (large) external funding, it's only fair to return everyone's personal donations here. The Manifund team tells me they'll revert the donations in the upcoming weeks. Thanks everyone here for their contributions--especially the token of trust means a lot to us.
Dalcy
over 1 year agoCandidate gene studies are known to be pretty horrible (a vast, vast majority of them do not replicate), and the correct standard are GWASes. My understanding is that your proposed targets DEC2 and ADRB1 are both candidate gene studies, and neither of them show up in the GWAS Catalog (https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/nSwaDrHunt3ohh9Et/cause-area-short-sleeper-genes?commentId=GCQf5qjG4LyEdEJov). Given that, I am quite skeptical of your specific gene targets. I am unfamiliar with the literature though and haven't read any of the references in your bibliography, and would change my mind if there has been any GWAS-based evidence in favor of DEC2 and ADRB1 recently (none showed up in the GWAS Catalog 2 years ago, according to the above EA forums). With that said, I'm very excited about the idea of sleep-reduction (and thank you for doing this work), and I'd be much more optimistic about this project if your gene targets were chosen via GWAS.
Sheikh Abdur Raheem Ali
over 1 year agoI would suggest reaching out to Andrej Karpathy: https://karpathy.bearblog.dev/finding-the-best-sleep-tracker/
Derik K
over 1 year agowishing you many sleepless nights!
Aaron Silverbook
almost 2 years agoif you think about it correctly, this is the most promising life extension angle available to us
isaak is smart, tenacious, and resourceful
no brainer; fuck it we ball
Vincent Weisser
almost 2 years agoImportant research project! Isaak, Helena are awesome and assembling a great team that should make progress on it
Thorge Lindner
almost 2 years agoincredible team, great project. we are so back 🔥
Brent Burdick
almost 2 years agoIsaak and Helena are some of the kindest and most competent people I've ever met, and I'm really excited that they're working on this.
Kyle Schiller
almost 2 years agoput me in the screencap
pablo cienfuegos
almost 2 years agoextremely promising
pablo cienfuegos
almost 2 years agoGreat, very promising
Dominik Scherm
almost 2 years agoAccelerate humanity 🫡
nfdfdldfl
almost 2 years agoseems like a very exciting and promising project
Austin Chen
almost 2 years agoI asked Isaak to put this on Manifund as soon as I saw his proposal:
I'm anti-sleeping-pilled: I think reducing sleep needs would be very beneficial to the world, and on a personal level have experimented with polyphasic sleep.
Though I'm no expert in biology and have no insight on how feasible this is, I'm very impressed with the credentials of this team and their advisors.
I strongly believe in Isaak himself, having worked with him on Future Forum and seen his trajectory since. (We asked him to serve as a Manifund regrantor in 2023.) I'd expect any project that Isaak's on to deliver extraordinary outcomes.
While it's different from the AI safety work that Manifund is mostly known for nowadays, ambitious moonshots like this are what I'm most personally interested in funding, and I'm excited to be able to support this initiative.