@carol Thanks for the chat! I think you make reasonable points here - it's hard for me to say what Sunlight's prioritization ought to be (re concerns about comparative advantage, etc). In general I think the path to impact for legible technical research outside of a frontier lab is narrow: if it's too inside-the-overton-window the labs are probably already pursuing it themselves, and with far more resources than independent researchers can provide. I see the primary role of independent researchers then as exploring somewhat-weird bets on alignment techniques and generating enough evidence to convince frontier labs to pursue them, and thereby moving those ideas inside-the-overton-window.
With regards to this research proposal, I think some aspects typify this more than others. I think that exploring Continual Learning (and in particular implementations that involve per-user or per-agent weight-specialization) have profound (mostly negative!) implications for alignment and I've seen no indications that this is on the radar of frontier labs. I think the Continual Learning part of this proposal is unlikely to be pursued if not funded here.
The RLVR part of this proposal is more borderline by this standard. Several months ago I would have said this is quite neglected by frontier labs, but some recent research (published after I made this proposal) coming from Ant-affiliated researchers (esp https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.17062) have begun exploring ideas very similar to what I proposed above. That said, this paper was published ~1 month ago, so while it might indicate that such research is becoming "more mainstream" it doesn't indicate that the opportunity for independent researchers to make a difference on this topic is closed.
As for the meta point on whether or not it's good for researchers to stay independent - I'm unsure! I think some number of researchers should definitely stay independent, but I don't know if this means that the marginal researcher would have more or less impact being independent. I suspect it depends a lot on the nature of what they're working on and also on how short timelines are.